← Back to the full owner's guide
The short answerNeither is better in general. A strategic buyer can pay more where it captures real savings but often folds your team and brand into its own, while a private equity buyer usually keeps management and the brand, so ask how long it plans to own you.
Who might buy your company
Different buyers want different things from your company, and they pay and behave accordingly. Knowing which kind sits across the table is half of negotiating with them.
| Buyer | What they want | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Strategic buyer (a competitor, supplier or customer) | Synergies: cost savings, new customers, new capabilities | Which of our roles overlap with yours? Will our brand and locations remain? |
| Traditional private equity fund | Buy, improve and resell within roughly five to seven years | When do you expect to sell this company again, and what happens to my team then? |
| Long-term private equity owner | Durable earnings and growth, held for the long run | What is your track record with the companies you hold? Can I speak to the founders? |
Five ways the two differ
- Price. If synergies are real and large, expect a strategic offer to reflect them. Where they are small, a private equity offer can match or beat it.
- Certainty. Private equity buyers usually arrive with financing arranged and a decision process they control. Strategic buyers may need board, regulatory or competition-law approvals, and their corporate priorities can change mid-deal.
- Your team and your brand. A strategic buyer often combines the company with its own operations, which removes overlapping roles and sometimes the brand. A private equity buyer usually keeps management and adds resources.
- Information risk. Sharing customer and pricing data with a competitor during diligence is a real exposure.
- Your role afterward. A strategic buyer may not need a former owner. A private equity buyer usually needs the leadership to stay. Decide which you want before you talk to either.
How to compare offers properly
Line up each offer on four points: what you would take home after debt, fees, escrow and tax; when you would receive it; how certain it is; and what happens to your people and your company afterward. Our page on how the sale of a business is structured shows the cash-at-closing arithmetic.
How a buyer runs diligence also tells you how it will own the company. Some treat diligence as a checklist with little discussion. Others work with your team to learn the business. The second kind shows you how it will behave as an owner.
Where Rundle fits
Rundle buys to hold. We have no planned exit date and structure each deal for a long hold. We keep the team, share equity with the people who help build the business and invest in technology to make the company stronger.
That suits owners who want the company they built to stay itself and be better resourced. If you want a clean break and a premium for synergies, a strategic buyer may serve you better, and we would tell you so.
Common questions
Does private equity pay more than a strategic buyer?
Sometimes, but usually a strategic buyer pays more when it can capture real cost savings or new revenue from owning your company. Private equity pays for the cash flow and growth your company already has and the improvements it can make. Where synergies are small, the gap narrows or reverses.
Will a private equity firm keep my management team?
Usually. Private equity buyers generally keep management in place and add resources, and a strategic buyer more often folds the company into its own operations. Ask any buyer in writing which roles, locations and brand names it plans to keep.
What is the difference between a traditional private equity fund and a long-term owner?
A traditional fund plans to buy, improve and resell within roughly five to seven years, so your team goes through a second ownership change. A long-term owner holds for durable earnings and growth with no planned sale date. Ask every private equity buyer when it expects to sell your company again.
Is it risky to share my data with a competitor?
Yes. Detailed customer and pricing data in a competitor's hands is a real risk if it walks away. Ask about clean-team arrangements before you share anything sensitive, and use a mutual NDA.
How do I check a buyer's track record?
Ask each buyer for the names of founders from companies it has acquired and call them. How a buyer treated the last owner is the best predictor of how it will treat you.
Keep reading
- How the sale of a business is structured
- How long it takes to sell a business
- For advisors: how Rundle works with brokers, lawyers and accountants
- The full owner's guide to selling your business
A straight conversation with a buyer
A first conversation with Rundle is confidential, carries no obligation, and starts with your priorities. If we are not the right fit, we will say so.
Or write to Ian Black, Managing Partner, at ian@rundlepartners.com.
This page is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Ranges and examples are illustrative and vary widely by business, sector and market conditions. Speak with qualified advisors about your own situation.